3d printing prosthetics 3D printing environment medicine architecture biotechnology prototyping medicine 3D scanning art food sustainability food biomedicine architecture 3d printing modelling animals news toys housing accessibility prosthetics forensics robots 3D scanning biomedicine selfies CGI drones solar cells laser scanning sustainability education robotics bioprinting printed food crime model making fashion stereolithography stereolithography flowers vacuum casting rapid prototyping beauty rapid prototyping miniatures surgery military body parts electronics military renewable energy TCFG MultiFab printer instruments construction home design 3d scanning 4D printing artificial intelligence archaeology restoration lego biomimicry mattel climate change biodiversity drones cosmetics design nanotechnology medical applications conservation CG innovation preservation bioprinting oceans sports transport developing countries prototyping assistive technology tabletop animal prosthetics vehicles creative apps laser scanners smartphone technology smartphones packaging personalisation fishing gaming music september developing world instruments medical supplies october tips starter guide ornaments filament decoration interior design costume cosplay multi-material printing off-grid ProJet MJP 3600 Printer materials archaeology gaming rockets technology home printers spines glass robots dangers firearms guns Skyscrapers Trump cycling surgery Great Barrier Reef building cities cancer lego make up films space full colour desktop jewellery ethics makeup plants travel future cellulose. eco friendly vegetables makeup beauty submarines stem cells bioethics 3Doodler developing world humanitarian aid sweets materials fitness money 3d printing news animal testing ocean exploration hydroponics agriculture bones baldness cure amazon pets printable objects halloween farming trainers animated film space F1 film industry study plastic surgery gun masks history art culinary fashion bridge oven motorbikes castles printed buildings engineering replacement teeth workplace hazards vehicles drugs printers cars automotive electronics musical instruments 3d Printing design software planning Escher printed housing modular architecture short run productions van gogh creative process 3D printing obama 3D printing and heart surgery replica pet models printing plants 3D printed chocolate 3D printed weapons earthquake-proof 3D printed column 3D metal printing decorations christmas 3D metal printers 3D printed dog noses 3D vases quadcopter project 3D printing women's makeup printing lipstick spooky selfies 3D printed jack-o-lantern competition Amazon 3D Printing Store 3D printed furniture 3D skulls and pumpkins houses short-run production tabletop games animal figures bjarki hallgrimsson 3d printer 3d models tabletop wargames 3d printed implants model prototype 3d printed prototypes traditional model making mini-you fabrication labs UAV body on a chip testable models 3d printed jewelry investment casting vacuum casting mars attacks mantic 3d figurines 3d selfies eco-friendly wedding cakes 3d print production prototypes household appliance recycling prototype 3D concept pizza tabletop gaming short run productions astronauts natural machines 3D glasses chefjet gifts PD Models interview live puppeteering terminator 2 star wars Jurassic Park Alien 3 Jar Jar Binks Gollum medical technology 3D computer graphics cinema eyes drill terminator news robotic arm CG modelling 3D models dancing robot creativity dust UV resin Carbon3D CV interviews office politics contact digitising conservation jobs creative business careers CAD digital sculpting metal powder digital migration Rolex 3d printed selfies jewelry 3D printing industry 3D modelling mining in space 3D topography maps 3D printing in mining motion art kinetic art superhero prosthethics 3D printed Batman suit 3D printed sculpture 3D printed dinosaur 3D printed food 3D printed bananas 3D printed urns 3D printed table accessories 3D printed ergonomic keyboard 3D printed laptop 3D printing in space design thinking design 3D printed mansion 3D printed prototyping 3D rendering 3D modelling wood project mosul statue 123D tool suite netfabb Hatra moon dust moon bases reprap recyclebot 3d printed mea SWaCH children medical use 3D print show Voxel8

The dark side to 3D Printing: The issues of bioethics in 3D bioprinting

The dark side to 3D Printing: The issues of bioethics in 3D bioprinting

In our current series, exploring the potential dark side of 3D printing technology, we have previously explored the dangers of potential criminal gun manufacture using 3D printers. In the following blog post, we will explore the issue of bioethics and 3D printing.

Bioethics and 3D printing

Bioethics is defined as the ethics surrounding medical and biological research. The rapid rise of bioprinting has seen many debates spark up on the topic of bioethics and 3D printing. What are the moral and ethical implications of 3D printing?  Such issues include whether there will be fair access to superior healthcare - will 3D printed medical treatments be easily accessible to all, or just too expensive to provide on a mass scale? Other people raise concerns about the safety of the 3D-printed biomaterial. In addition, other groups ask whether it is ethical to use 3D printed biomaterials at all.

A problem vs a solution

It is fairly easy to argue that 3D printing can potentially offer many needed solutions to current medical problems. For example, in one of our past posts we explored how 3D printers can be used to print off uniquely tailored organs, bones, and other physical matter that will not be rejected by the human body. Imagine a world in which people have easy access to healthy organs and do not have to rely on willing organ donors.

The potential benefits of using 3D printers in medicine are undeniable, but many do raise various dangers that we need to consider.

Issues of cost

3D bio-printing is time-consuming and as a result expensive, as Linda Griffith, Director of the Center of Gynepathology Research at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, explains in the Guardian:

"If you 3D print a dress, or a gun, it is pretty easy to tell right away if it works," she said. "The assays to tell whether bioprinting works are really, really time consuming and expensive."

The time-consuming nature of bioprinting may mean that the final product is expensive and can only be afforded by the richest in society; this, of course, brings up a serious ethical issue. If treatment is available, is it right that only some can afford it? Right to life and right to health are two of the most basic human rights and access to good healthcare should be available to all.

Issues of safety

Using 3D printers in medical cases raises some safety concerns, ABC eloquently notes the potential safety issues of 3D printed biomaterial:

“In the future, 3D printing may be used in combination with stem cell derived cell lines. How can we know in advance that these treatments are safe? Unlike the case of developing a new drug, a stem cell therapy can't be tested on a sizable number of healthy people prior to being tested on patients and then, finally, being made available as a standard treatment.”

Unlike traditional medical interventions, 3D-printed medical interventions may be hard to efficiently and swiftly test; there is always the possibility that the printed material may be rejected by the human body.

Moral debates

Although moral arguments are less commonly waged today, some groups of people hold ‘moral’ objections to 3D bioprinting. For example, some religious groups feel that bioprinting is a way for scientists to play God.

On the other side of the debate, bioprinting could effectively help millions of people suffering from serious medical illnesses. So, could we also not argue that we have a moral responsibility to embrace the most sophisticated and effective technologies available to us?

Tagged with: bioprinting, bioethics, stem cells